Difference between Ketchup and Catsup

Main Difference

Etymologists express that both the word ketchup and catsup are acquired from a Malay word “kechap” or ‘kecap’. While the Anglicization of the word happened from the Malay word, there is a supposition that the starting points of this Malay word really lie in some Cantonese lingo. Individuals will be astonished to note that this unique “kechap” had no tomatoes. If truth to be told, it was a fixing that is made of saltwater fish and different flavors. The Malay rendition of the “kechap” had some soy sauce which was sweet and added to it to make it tangier. An Anglicized form of “kechap” appears to have been made as right on time as 1690 when it was called “catchup” from which the term of the “catsup” started. References to the Malay “kechap” and the Anglicized word “ketchup” have been made in the book ‘An Account of Trade in India’ by Charles Lockyer in the year 1711. So to some degree, one can say that “catchup” pre-dates the word ‘ketchup’.


It is additionally said that the principal formula of ketchup showed up in the book ‘The Complete Housewife’ that was written by Elizabeth Smith in the year of 1727. For individuals who has the capacity to get a duplicate of this formula and read it, they would clearly encounter some kind of a frustration and disappointment as the formula contained the ingredients consisting of the anchovies, white wine, shallots, flavors, for example, ginger, nutmeg and cloves, vinegar, lemon peel, and pepper, but no tomatoes at all. It took the world nearly two centuries from that point to present the element of tomatoes as a base for ketchup. After that time, most ketchup formulas utilized the mushrooms or walnuts as the base. For the preparation of the ketchup, you don’t have to ignore the basic ingredients which are composed of the tomatoes, vinegar, sugar, salt, allspice, cloves, and cinnamon. The Onions, celery, and other vegetables are added for making it spicy. The ketchup was known as tomato, soy in addition by the nineteenth century and it is true that the early tomato versions were much thinner as compared to the present ones. The former ketchup editions were well furnished with a consistency more like a soy or Worcestershire sauce. The primary type of ketchup was the tomato ketchup in the United States by the end of the nineteenth century.


The word of the “catchup” was made even amidst the nineteenth century as prove by a story from Scribner’s Magazine dating 1859 that specified ‘mushroom catchup’. Notice of the changed adaptation of the word ‘catchup’, “catsup” appears to have been started by Jonathan Swift in the year 1730. These days, while most producers and shoppers overall utilize the word ‘ketchup’, there are still individuals who utilize alternate variations of the word ‘” ‘catchup’, “catsup” or ‘katsup’. What’s more, there are still “catsup” formulas available for use where tomato does not shape the base, for example, apple catsup and Picante catsup. The major ingredients of the Catsup may be comprised of the tomatoes, onions, cayenne, sugar, white vinegar, cloves, cinnamon, celery seed and salt.

Key Differences

  • Both the words are only two distinctive anglicized renditions of the first Malay word, “kechap” which appears to have been obtained from a Cantonese vernacular.
  • While both words started around the same time, all things considered, “catchup” (which the origin of the Catsup) appears to have begun sooner than that of the “ketchup”
  • Though “catsup” is still being used. On the other hand, the more prominent variant utilized worldwide is ‘ketchup’.

Video Explanation


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *